Sunday, 27 February 2011

First time coming up from dropback without turning the feet out, also Diet and injury watch update

'Practicing on painkillers' poll still up over on the right of the blog. ( feel free to comment anonymously on this if you like ). I think it's an interesting topic, lots of aches and pains in a practice like Ashtanga, I'm sure we're not all using salt baths and caster oil wraps.

Think I mentioned a little while ago ( Jan 2011) the new approach I've been taking to dropping back. Basically I'm allowing my heels to lift a little as I drop and come back up. I know, I know, isn't this just switching one 'bad' habit for another. Well possibly, but it's allowing me to have my feet closer together and something interesting is happening in my hips though I can't really explain it yet, will come back to that in another post. No matter how much I practiced before I didn't seem to be able to stop turning the feet out (although I did get it down to turning out just the one) yet here I get the feeling that I might be able to eliminate the heel lift altogether.

Whatever, I kind of like the feel of this, can get a very soft, slow landing, almost touch right down to the mat on a good day, it's interesting, I like it.
Here it is from the frount to focus on the feet, also a shot from the side, at the end, so you can see the extent of the heel lift. Still work in progress but it's coming.

This head on, camera at an angle shot looks really strange, distorting somehow but is showing the feet not moving ( though watch the first toe ) which is the point.



DIET
I've allowed my diet ( by diet I just mean eating habits not Atkins or anything faddish) to get a little out of hand. Krishnamacharya would say that controlling your diet is one of the most important prescriptions for the yoga student. Here he quotes from the Gita Saram

For whom there is neither excess nor less
of sleep, food activity
For him alone it is possible
to attain the state of yoga

Well I still only eat two meals a day but since the back problem I've noticed I'm snacking a little during the day. People have been bringing in biscuits, cakes, sweets and I've had the odd bar of chocolate from the work snack machine. None of this I really need, comfort food I think. I've also been having a Martini most evenings ( although a weak one) rather than just on Saturday ( love the clean taste at the moment) and I've noticed that the two meals a day have become larger amounts of food than before, more than I need. All just reflects the lack of discipline in my practice while this back issue is messing with it.

So next week, a little more discipline of my life I think. Control freak, you think ?

Injury update : Rest day
Took the Saturday rest day for a change, as an experiment, no painkillers no practice. Back hurt like hell all day, well most of the day, seemed to loosed up around 4pm. that suggests the practice in the morning is helping as I tend to feel fine all day and I only take the painkillers once a day around 5am.

This morning was Intermediate including the dropbacks above and I feel fine, loose, mobile.

Probably give the painkillers another week then bin any that are left and practice without after that.

16 comments:

Boodiba said...

I was kind of lifting the heels & having narrower feet when I first met JC and he jumped all OVER that. In his opinion that is definitely the worse of the two evils. That's only one opinion though of course.

I know David Swenson does a big heel lift.

Karen said...

Sweeney talks about this in his most recent book. He is all for people experimenting with heels up/feet splayed/wider/narrower stance. Says it's about individual mechanics.

That said, when I visit the authorized teacher in Tucson, the preference is for splaying over lifting. She asked if I feel any stress in my knees as I duck to come up. I said not at all, and she pretty much ignored it after that.

I like going down there for visits, because I always find that the stuff I'm stressing about isn't any big deal -- she takes a long view of practice -- you do it every day and eventually it'll all sort out. No OCD. I appreciate that.

Grimmly said...

Afraid I disagree with your Time magazine 'yogi of the year' : ) here (saw the pics on FB nice job). I'm pretty sure I can get from my heel lift here to minimal lift to flat feet with this approach. Seem to be able to work on that getting the hips forward and up thing going here. Turning the feet out was beginning to feel like a dead end.

What does Greig and Chris over at Newsweek have to say on this?

Grimmly said...

Karen yours came in just as I was replying to Boodie.

Yes yes, long view and experimentation.

Of course I'm coming to heels up after a couple of years of turning out my feet and dropping back and coming up. My knees and hips are nice and flexible by now and it feels a more elegant approach. Perhaps I wouldn't be finding that if I started off with the heels up and maybe i would have experienced some knee and hip stress.

Karen said...

Yeah, the long view in Ashtanga is decades. I like that perspective!

Newsweek. LOL!

Claudia said...

HA HA HA, I am still laughing at the Time mangazine and Newseek thing.... ha ha ha

G, I believe that sometimes we gotta do what we gotta do, for example in my case this is conveniently great as I am taking a break from the whole thing, those dropbacks were exausting me!

I love the video! good job it looks great and I am sure it will eventually come, you are doing the practice so... all is coming.

Great idea on the poll, just voted "a few times"... a LOT of people seem to be "never", wow! I even felt a bit embarrased but will stand by my vote...

Grimmly said...

That's one of the great things about Ashtanga Claudia, you focus on jump back for a bit then stick em on the back burner and work on your drop back or coming up. few steps forward then leave them alone while you play with Marichi D or Kapo or the duck...

Thanks for voting but what's this 'a few times' : )

エスタ said...

Nice one! Hope to be getting back to drop backs now that full practice is back on the menu. I too resorted to the chocolate with my injury, sad but I needed the comfort, oh what a bad lady I've been ; ) Good luck!

Claudia said...

Well, you call it once or twice.... You say tomato I say tomato, hee hee

Grimmly said...

Sorry claudia, i thought you were say that you voted a few times IE ticked different boxes. Thought it might be closer to 50% oh well, we can feel guilty together.

Glad your full practice is back エスタ still find it strange that I have a dodgy back and yet backbending is fine, yoga's weird. It's a small thing the controlling your diet but it's a nice way of introducing discipline throughout your day rather than just in those couple of hours in the morning.

Helen said...

Hi Grimmly,

Have you tried a natural anti inflammatory like turmeric. Really not a fan of practicing with pain meds as I like to know how it really feels when I practice. I have taken turmeric before practice though.

hongkongstuey said...

I'm a big fan of the heel lift (years of Anusara classes drilled the benefits of this over 'duck-footing' in to me) and it does help get rid of both evils eventually - you just need to keep the legs nice and juiced up to avoid the knees splaying out.

Will probably be experimenting with the pain killer thing over the next few days (weeks/months...) as my lower right back let out a definate complaint when i lifted my heels in kurmasana yesterday. Could barely bend forward to touch the floor in this mornings practice...

Grimmly said...

Hi Helen. Tumeric, forgotten about that, think i still have a big bag of it around somewhere from when I had my old knee injury play up. How do you take yours, I used a Krishnsamacharya recipe with milk, honey and Almond essence.

Hey Stuey. I'm curious what are the benefits Anusura mention for the heel lift? So glad sometimes that i'm a home ashtangi and free to experiment this way and that and not tied down to whatever preferences and prejudices a particular teacher/shala has. One guru? Sure, the inner one.

Sorry about your back. Something dodgy about that supta K heel lift, overkill?

Claudia said...

Oh I see what you mean... and yes I just noticed it is a bit more balanced now phewwww

hongkongstuey said...

my understanding is that duck footing causes your sit bones to contract and results in a pinching/contraction in the lower back

If you lift the heels instead and keep the knees drawing towards the midline this can't happen and the lower back stays nice and open (try it) - which is better both posturally (is that a word?) and for the flow of energy etc.

There's so many different views on 'correct' alignment and I've had conflicting advice from numerous very experienced teachers all of whom i trust. I just tend to go with what feels best for me these days - and in this case its a little lifting of the heels

Grimmly said...

Thanks for that Stuey. Agreed, 'correct alignment' is a hot or rather heated topic for usually mild mannered yogis, what's that all about. Always a joy watching those old 70/80's Ashtanga videos, ahhh innocent times : )

Recent Comments

Counter

Followers